It Had To Be You (2000) Apr 2026

While critics noted its predictable tropes, many praise the undeniable chemistry between Henstridge and Vartan, calling it an "adult love story with scruples". The film also features a strong supporting cast, including as Charlie’s former NYPD partner and Olivia d’Abo as Anna’s vibrant friend. You can currently find it streaming on platforms like Peacock Premium or available for rent on Amazon Prime Video .

: Look closely at the cast list—this movie marked the film debut of a young Emmy Rossum . It Had to Be You (2000)

: Although the film was produced and shot in 1998 , contractual issues kept it in limbo for years until it was finally released in 2000 and distributed by Regent Entertainment in 2001. While critics noted its predictable tropes, many praise

: This was the first film in Natasha Henstridge's career that was not rated R; it earned a family-friendly PG rating . : Look closely at the cast list—this movie

: As they spend three days navigating a parade of cynical wedding planners and eccentric advisors, they begin to bond over a shared love for Frank Sinatra and realize they might be marrying the wrong people. Interesting Facts & Trivia

The story follows two strangers, (Natasha Henstridge) and Charlie Hudson (Michael Vartan), who are both independently planning their weddings at the Plaza while their respective fiancés are away in Europe for work.