The most significant moment of the episode occurs in its final seconds. In a flashback to the 1619 cliffside, the hooded figure finally removes his cloak to reveal the face of (Bill Skarsgård) from Season 1.

: We meet Amity, a settler in "New Jerusalem" cast out with her lover, the preacher Augustin, after being accused of witchcraft. Starving and desperate, Amity encounters a hooded figure on a cliffside—an "angel" who brings fertility back to the sick land.

: "Ace" Merrill is revealed to be the current vessel for the spirit of Pastor Augustin. He is overseeing the renovation of the Marsten House, preparing it as a headquarters for the resurrected cult. The Return of "The Kid"

The episode splits its time between a grim origin story in 1619 and the present-day 400th-anniversary celebration of Castle Rock.